Foolish Hope vs. Wise Hope
In his sermon, “The Right to Hope”, Paul Tillich makes a distinction between foolish hope and wise hope.
Any fool can hope. We can hope to win the lottery. We can hope that some, as-yet-unknown rich uncle will die and leave us millions. We can hope that science will discover a way to genetically modify chocolate so that it removes fat. And we can sit and watch TV waiting for our hopes to be fulfilled.
Yet is that any more foolish than a childless couple going through all sorts of gyrations in order to get pregnant and failing over and over again and having their hopes worn down like a river wears down the stones in its streambed until, as the Bible delicately puts it, “It ceases to be with her after the manner of women” (Gen. 18:11)?
Tillich says that there is a difference.
Genuine hope is hope in something in the future in which the seed is already present.
“In the bulb there is the flower,
In the seed an apple tree,
Unrevealed until its season,
Something God, alone, can see.”
The wise see in the tiniest things signs of real transformation. It’s not just the daffodils that are signs of spring, but the sharing of a loaf of bread and a cup of wine by all sorts of people: rich and poor, powerful and weak, young and old, brave and fearful that is a sign of the kingdom of heaven.
But there is something else about the hope of the wise. It needs to be strong enough to die and to be reborn.
There is little doubt that Abraham and Sarah’s hope that they would have a biological child died some years earlier. That’s why they laugh when God tells them that they will soon hold their child in their arms. The laughter is the rebirth of hope.
We laugh when the hope we thought we gave up a long time ago as a foolish hope peeks up out of the snow of despair. We laugh at ourselves for ever hoping. We laugh at all the work we put in to trying to fulfill that hope. We laugh at how disappointed we were at first when the hope failed to materialize. We laugh at the way we have accommodated to not having that hope anymore. And we laugh at the foolishness of believing, even for a second that a living hope could be reborn in us.